The Ultimate Website Audit Checklist for Small Businesses

August 19, 2025

Disclosure: This post may contain affiliate links. If you purchase using these links, we may earn a small commission at no additional cost to you. We only recommend tools we know and trust ourselves.

Running a successful small business means staying on top of many things, and your website is one of the most critical. It’s your 24/7 storefront, your digital brand ambassador, and a powerful engine for growth. But what happens when that engine starts to sputter? A regular website audit is the key to keeping your site healthy, fast, and visible to potential customers.

A technical website audit can seem intimidating, but in reality, it's a systematic process for identifying and fixing issues that could be hurting your business. In this comprehensive guide, we’ll answer the question, "what is a site audit," explain why regular checks are non-negotiable, and give you a powerful website audit checklist to follow.

So, without further ado, let’s dive right in!

What is a Site Audit?

A site audit is a comprehensive and detailed analysis of your website. Its purpose is to uncover errors and problem whether they are technical, related to content, or user experience. They can be resolved to improve your site’s performance, its ranking in search results, and, ultimately, your business’s revenue.

Depending on your goals, a site audit can focus on a few key areas:

For small business owners, the most impactful starting point is a technical website audit. This type of audit identifies critical issues like indexation problems, broken redirects, and slow page loading speeds, all of which can significantly harm your SEO and user experience. It's the kind of check we’ll focus on in this article, and it forms the foundation of any successful digital strategy.

Why Regular Website Audits are Critical for Small Businesses

Think of a website audit as a regular health check-up for your most important digital asset. It’s not just about fixing problems when they arise, it’s about proactive maintenance that keeps your site running smoothly and your business growing.

A comprehensive technical audit of website performance helps you:

Boost SEO and Rankings: By identifying and fixing technical issues that hinder search engine crawlers, you make it easier for Google to understand and rank your site.
Improve User Experience (UX): A fast, well-structured, and error-free website keeps visitors on your site longer, reducing bounce rates and increasing the likelihood of a sale.
Prevent Performance Problems: Regular checks prevent issues like broken links or slow load times from piling up, which can lead to a significant drop in traffic and conversions.
Stay Ahead of Competitors: A strong, optimized website gives you a competitive edge. A competitor website audit can reveal their strengths and weaknesses, helping you refine your own strategy.

The frequency of your audits depends on your website's size and how often you update it, but a solid baseline for most small businesses is a quarterly audit. For larger sites or those with frequent updates, a monthly check is recommended.

Your Comprehensive Website Auditing Checklist

If you're ready to start improving your site, this website auditing checklist will walk you through all the basic checks you need to perform. We’ll go through each point in more detail, but this list provides a great overview of the process.

Website Audit Checklist

Crawlability & Indexability: Ensure search engines can easily access and index your site’s pages.
Site Structure: Check for a logical and clear navigation hierarchy.
Page Speed & Performance: Analyze page loading times, especially on mobile devices.
Mobile-Friendliness: Verify that your site provides a seamless experience for mobile users.
On-Page SEO Elements: Review meta titles, descriptions, headers, and image alt text for optimization.
Technical SEO: Look for issues with sitemaps, robots.txt, canonical tags, and structured data.
Content Quality: Assess for duplicate content, thin content, and relevancy.
Internal & External Links: Identify and fix broken links and review link attributes.
Security: Check for HTTPS implementation and other security vulnerabilities.

How to Perform a Website Audit Mindfully: A Step-by-Step Guide

Manual auditing is a lengthy and resource-intensive process. For most small business owners, it’s far more efficient to use specialized site scanners, such as Cohesive Digital’s Website Audit, in conjunction with Google Search Console and Google Analytics. This is one of the best SEO audit tools because it scans the entire site, identifies dozens of technical errors, and provides recommendations on how to fix them.

Here is a guide on how to perform a website audit using our recommended tool.

1. Set Up Your Automated Audit

To get started, you can configure an automated audit to run on a schedule.

Set up a Scanning Schedule: Choose to run the audit manually, or set it to perform automatically on a weekly or monthly basis. You can also get email notifications once the audit is finished.
Choose Pages to Scan: You can scan all pages starting from your homepage, scan pages listed in your XML sitemap, or add a custom list of pages.
Select Scanning Rules: Configure how the tool’s bot will crawl your site, including whether it should follow or ignore instructions in your robots.txt file, or ignore "noindex" and "nofollow" directives.
Set up a Parser: To ensure an accurate audit, you can manually choose which bot to use for crawling. This is particularly useful if your website restricts certain crawlers.

2. Review the Audit Results

When the in-depth scan is complete, you’ll have a wealth of data in the Website Audit module.

Get the Bigger Picture with the Overview Report: This is where you’ll find your Website Health Score—a key feature that’s calculated based on the number and severity of issues found. You’ll also see key metrics like Core Web Vitals, domain metrics, and HTTP status codes.
Analyze Issues with the Issue Report: This report categorizes errors into errors, warnings, and notices. Errors are the most critical issues to fix, while warnings are medium-severity and notices are minor. Each issue comes with a description and suggestions on how to fix it.
Focus on Specific Pages with the Crawled Pages Tab: This section shows every page the bot has found, along with the number of issues detected. You can use filters to find pages with specific problems, like private pages that aren't blocked from indexing.
Conduct Link Research with the Found Links Tab: Here you can identify all internal and external links on your site and use filters to quickly detect and fix broken links (status code 404).

Prioritizing Website Audit Fixes

Now that you have all of this information, you need a plan. Prioritizing fixes allows you to get the best results in less time and with fewer resources.

Assess the Severity of the Problem: Use the tool’s categorization (errors, warnings, notices) as a guide. Fix the critical errors first, as these have the most significant negative impact on your site.
Consider Page Importance: Start with the pages that matter most to your business. This could be your homepage, key product pages, or pages that drive the most organic traffic. You can use Google Analytics to identify these pages.
Consider the Scope of the Problem: If an issue affects your entire site rather than just individual pages, it should be a high priority. Fixing global problems first will improve your site as a whole.
Start with "Quick Wins": Use an impact/effort matrix to identify tasks that require less effort but deliver a high impact. This method helps you get a quick return on your time and resources, providing a solid foundation for more complex fixes.

Remember, prioritization should be a collaborative effort. Involve your development team or a trusted technical partner to determine the time and effort required to solve a problem.

Final Thoughts

A regular, comprehensive website audit is essential for anyone who wants to climb to the top of the SERPs and win the hearts of their users. All of this, however, is only possible if you use a high-quality SEO tool to check the site. It should be configurable, provide detailed reports on every issue, and allow you to compare audit results to monitor the effectiveness of your fixes.

Our Website Audit was designed with all these considerations in mind and updated regularly to provide accurate information for detected issues. For an in-depth technical audit of website performance, be sure to check out Cohesive Digital’s website audit service and try it for yourself!

For more information on traffic to your site, check out our website traffic checker.

Start your free trial (No credit card required) with SE Ranking - The Platform Powering Cohesive Digital's SEO Toolkit and take control of your website's ranking!